Complementary and Alternative
Medicine (CAM) is becoming increasingly popular in the United States. Americans
are starting to seek a more holistic approach to health, and are supplementing
conventional Western Medicine with natural products and services that are
considered to help promote wellness and prevent diseases. CAM can be defined as
“a set of medical and healthcare systems, practices, and products that are not
part of that country’s own tradition and are not integrated into the dominant
healthcare system” (NCCAM 2002).
The kind of people in the United
States that are most likely to use CAM are women (Barnes et al. 2004), people
with higher household income ethnic minorities (Barnes et al. 2004), and people
with chronic health problems such as anxiety, back pain, and headaches (Astin
1998). Studies have shown that people aren’t necessarily dissatisfied with US
medicine, but are starting to use CAM as a means to take control of their own
health, increase their options for treatment, and not rely solely on
conventional medical care (Eisenberg et al 2001).
The top 10 CAM treatments in the
United States are (Barnes et al. 2004):
1) Prayer for
one’s own health
2) Prayer for
someone else’s health
3) Non-vitamin,
nonmineral, natural products
4) Deep Breathing
Exercises
5) Prayer Group
6) Meditation
7) Chiropractic Care
8) Yoga
9) Massage
10) Diet-based
therapies.
What is interesting about CAM, and
how it is used and perceived in the United States, is that in many developing
countries, CAM practices and treatments are considered traditional medicine
that have been used for hundreds of years. Any given practice can
simultaneously be traditional or alternative depending on the location of its
use. Some countries (China, North and South Korea, and Vietnam) have also fully
integrated traditional medicine into their healthcare systems (WHO 2003). For
example, in China, traditional herbs constitute 30-50% of total medicinal
consumption. About 80% of the world’s population uses traditional systems of
medicine for health care with plants as the dominant component (Mukherjee &
Wahile 2006).
Certain diseases and conditions
have also sparked a disproportionate use of complementary and alternative
treatments. Cancer, for example, due to its expensive and extensive treatment
regime, has caused the afflicted individuals to resort to other methods of
treatment as well such as prayer, diet, and meditation. In Brazil, up to 89% of
cancer patients use CAM (Holtz 2008). Current research efforts are also trying
to evaluate the effectiveness of immune modulation or enhancement, which if
successful, could help enhance or inhibit the immune system’s responses (NCCAM
2002). This could be particularly helpful to those afflicted with HIV/AIDS in
countries all over the world.
As CAM increases in popularity, and
more evidence-based research emerges on different treatments, public health
officials should consider implementing certain CAM techniques into policy and
interventions. Based on a nation’s resources (natural and economic), it might
be a more viable option to integrate alternative medicine into the traditional
mode of healthcare delivery. Overall, people are finding different methods that
they believe will help benefit their health, and I think this is a good
opportunity to bridge the gap in cultural differences in the practice of
medicine.
Astin, J. A. 1998. “Why
patients use alternative medicine.” JAMA
279:1548-1553.
Barnes et al. 2004. CAM use among adults: United States, 2002.
Advance data from vital and health statistics. Retrieved from http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/ad/ad343.pdf.
Eisenberg D.M. et al.
2001. “Perceptions about complementary therapies relative to conventional
therapies among adults who use both: results from a national survey.” Annuals of Internal Medicine 135:344-351.
Holtz, Carol. 2008. Global Health Care: Issues and Policies
Sudbury, MA: Jones and Bartlett Publishers.
Mukherjee, P.K, &
Wahile, A. 2006. Integrated approaches toward drug development from Ayurveda and
other Indian system of medicines. Journal
of Ethnopharmacology 103:25-35.
NCCAM. 2002. Get The Facts: What is Complementary and
Alternative Medicine (CAM)? Retrieved December 4, 2013 from http://nccam.nih.gov/health/whatiscam/
WHO. 2003. Traditional Medicine. Retrieved December
3, 2013 from http://www.who.int/mediacentre/factsheets/fs134.pdf .
I find CAM a difficult pill to swallow. I think that CAM can have a substantial impact upon the health of many people. However, research must clearly suggest that these techniques are effective. I would love to read an article that discusses the relative effectiveness of say, meditation compared to depression medication. Simply put, I don't think anything should be prescribed unless proven effective. This undermines the confidence that patients have in their physicians and it is not an responsible use of knowledge. However, it is the health professionals duty to search out methods of healing. This may be an up-hill battle as interest groups such as big-name pharmaceutical companies have considerable lobbying power against efficacious alternative methods that make their products obsolete. As a health professional, I would love to advocate for CAM. I just want robust evidence to base my decisions off of. A decision made for health in a clinical setting is not borne by the clinician, but rather by the patient. If a more effective method is available, that is what I would want to prescribe. There simply needs to be an evaluation of the relative effectiveness or pros and cons of each in order to convince the medical community (and population at large) what is effective, and what is not.
ReplyDeleteI would agree with Barry wholeheartedly. I would also like to stress how CAM needs to be supplementary and not replace normal medical care. Something that has been happening is parents attempting to "pray away" sicknesses. An example is found here: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2205306/Russel-Brandi-Bellew-Faith-healer-parents-avoid-jail-Austin-Sprout-16-dies.html
ReplyDeleteI am curious to see if CAM effects, in general, go beyond that of a simple placebo effect. I am also interested in the psychological effects of CAM usage. Coming from a psych background, I wonder if going through these alternative medicinal routes eases the stress/worry of medical treatment or increases feelings of hope. What would be even more interesting is if you could see how feelings of hope influence success of medical treatment...